We recommend that you pay off any debt you legitimately incur, but there is a downside to doing this. For instance, when attempting to purchase a home. People are such in a hurry to close on their mortgage, ignoring the fact that paying a simple collection item can totally torpedo their mortgage loan.
Here Is The Problem:
For instance, a mortgage customer learns that there is a collection item on his credit report and most of the time have no idea what it is. Sometimes, it’s the product of identity theft. The customer thinks that the path of least resistance is to pay the collection and it will come off the credit report. The opposite happens almost every time.
When you pay a collection item, two things happen;
1. The collection item is frequently reclassified as a “paid” collection item; its not removed.
2. You are admitting that it’s your debt. Hence, any chance of getting a credit repair company, credit bureau, or court, to remove that item off of your credit report goes down the drain.
So what should you do?
If the collection item is the product of identity theft
Go get a police report. Its simple and painless. Take your credit report to the police station, show the detective the item that is not yours and get a report. We will send a dispute letter for you and attach the police report. We can usually get that item removed within 30 days.
If the collection item is legitimate
Do not pay it until you get an agreement with the debt collector to REMOVE the collection item from your credit report altogether in exchange for payment. Be sure to get the agreement in writing before your client pays the debt. Get the debt collector’s fax and email to be sure that you send a confirmation of the agreement to the debt collector if they refuse to give you something in writing to memorialize the agreement. Do NOT settle for a notation of “paid in full” .